• 3 Posts
  • 65 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle










  • There’s no need to be angry just because you’re mistaken.

    I think you are very much mistaken there.

    when your arguments get rejected, you try to make me angry by saying “calm down”? that is pretty pathetic discussion tactic.

    VISOR:

    • no proof it can match the visible spectrum of human eyes, in spite of your lies and unfounded assumptions
    • causes pain and headaches
    • can malfunction
    • can get lost or stolen
    • can be exploited by romulan intelligence to turn you into zombie

    no reasonable person consider that superior to human eyes, which is why there weren’t people standing in line to gouge their eyes out and replace them with visor.

    i don’t plan to run in circles with you until xmas, so bye and welcome to my blocklist


  • Incorrect. There have been humans born with an extra come in their eyes due to a mutation, and those people could see extra colours. There are people who get damaged lenses on their eyes that let them see a bit of ultraviolet.

    there is no way to know what they see and how it differs from normal sight.

    Data called them superior too.

    yeah, this whole discussion started by me pointing this fact and the consequent contradiction. nice circle you have there.

    It’s not wrong to call it superior.

    the only person in the world who was qualified to decide that abandoned it as soon as he could. that makes it very wrong to call them superior.



  • An insect that sees ultraviolet light doesn’t see it how we see it

    It was showing a representation in the visible light spectrum of what the visor can detect

    the insect’s brain evolved to process insect’s available sensory input, so did human’s. so geordi would see exactly the same reducted picture that we see on the viewscreen, because that is the only thing our brain knows how to do.

    and you are still narrowing this discussion to subset of the facts. there is still the fact of visor being piece of technology that can be lost, malfunction, causes occasional pain and allows its wearer to be hacked by romulan intelligence. i don’t call that superior to my eyes.

    anyway, i don’t think we will progress further in this discussion, so until next time 🖖


  • There’s also nothing there that shows or says he can’t see the visible light spectrum.

    there is, it is exactly there on the screen, his perception of visible spectrum is just one step above nothing. would you want to see like that? accompanied by occasional technical problems and pain? would you call that superior to your eyes?

    He would see it differently than what appears on the viewscreen.

    that is just unfounded assumption, if you want to argue like that, you can make up literally anything and the discussion loses sense (not that the level of sense was very high anyway 😆)




  • I don’t think that’s contradictory at all though.

    Geordi wanted to be able to see [naturally], but his visor is superior to human eyes in that it can see things that humans can’t naturally see.

    we are nitpicking here, but if i amputate your hand and stitch can opener at its end, you can now do something normal human hand cannot, but i don’t think anyone would call that superior, or prefer it to their own hand.

    if geordi decided that after considering all factors, he would rather have normal eyes, then that is definition of “not superior” to me.

    and just a reminder that this is the extraordinary experience we are talking about. i am definitely choosing my eyes 😆