• 1 Post
  • 24 Comments
Joined 1 month ago
cake
Cake day: May 16th, 2026

help-circle










  • I do remember the line from the BSG Miniseries where they are talking about caclulating their first jump. Something like, “If we are off by even a few percentage points, we could end up in the middle of the sun!” and I was thinkijng, “Like, you’d be off in your calculations by a whole percentage point?” I mean, I know there’s no networked computers allowed on the galactica, but a calculator should be able to handle it.

    Edit: Though, now in retrospect, I imagine a first jump calculation would involve estimating mass, which is going to be imprecise. Probably after your first jump you can infer your mass from your location.











  • Thinking about this more, I think The Enterprise has a realism advantage in that most of the crew has subject-area competence–that is they have to know engineering, or medicine, or navigation, or tacitcs, or whatever. These are things that can be taught and tested and developed.

    I think where The Federation Office corps strays is in a few areas:

    1a) multiple areas of competence–like everyone is always WORKING so hard to get BETTER at everything, like why do people need to also master classical instruments as well as advanced fluid dynamics? It reflects a striving typical among Ivy League merit-obsessed individuals, which is a real thing, but it also doesn’t ever criticize this mindset.

    1b) the Science is Science trope, common SF trope --where a doctor might also know about quantum capacitors and an engineer might have enough basic biology to whipup a cure for a rapidly spreading degenerative illness. I still remember an episode with Kira and Odo getting stranded because neither of them knew shit about fixing engines and I’m still recovering from the shock.

    1. Emotional intelligence – everyone seems to be on a pretty even keel, which is unusual for the driven types from 1a.

    2. Command as meritocracy. Maybe someone in the military can speak to this, but in my view organizations have always been chock-a-block with ass-kissers and incompetent aristocrats. An actual command consistently competent is less believable than teleporters.

    I think the Orville really shines at 1a–they have some seriously flawed characters.