You must log in or register to comment.
Stop adding random crap and if anything just make a proper modding API like they said they would a long time ago. Data packs are progress but people still need to go to something like Forge or Fabric for the real in-depth mods.
get rid of Microsoft
We’ve been wishing since the '90s.
That doesn’t seem feasible, and if that were to happen it’s probably gonna be an even bigger company that would buy it.
There aren’t many bigger companies in the world than Microsoft, to be fair. In tech you’re looking at…Apple? And I think that’d be it.
Tencent is a bit further down the list from Microsoft in terms of overall value but I’d assume they’d be next in line to buy.
I got rid of myself from playing it when they wouldn’t stop spamming me about changing to Microsoft or whatever the hell those emails were about. I didn’t read em, didn’t ask for em, didn’t care.
Give our freedom back, it is a game about freedom Or they are not winning this class action lawsuit
Agreed
Revolutionized? I don’t think so. The core concept of the game hasn’t changed and stuff is getting added to it since. It’s so simple, there’s really no need to change anything, only just extending.
It’s like LEGO really, which too doesn’t really need any revolutionary changes.
I think the current dev cycle is harming hype for the game. The way snapshots work, there’s no surprises in the updates anymore, and like big creators do whole series in the snapshots before they even come out. There is a community issue of going into an update with it feeling “solved” unless you just blanket avoid update videos. Like when we get it on our server, I’m gonna speedrun get 2 pale logs, 1 sapling, and a creaking heart, get them into an ender chest, and the farm I think will work best is essentially already designed. There’s small hype as snapshots roll out but on the big day…few people play the new release (because like Doc said in his video today… everyone waits for mods) and most people have already experienced most of it via snapshot streamers. It feels like this dev cadence is destroying any hype for releases, and by making more releases, it’s putting strain on volunteers.
I don’t know a fix; the snapshot system is a great feedback mechanism but by putting the game out there nearly in full it removes hype. Also, the snapshots should give mod developers time to build, but it isn’t panning out that way. Like Bundles and armadillos weren’t gonna get more players to play/come back to the game, and the people already playing that use mods didn’t upgrade to it. There’s a very narrow subset of people who that update benefitted, but for a lot of volunteer devs it put a ton of work on their plates.
I think one major thing they could do is limit datapack and resourcepack revisions to 1.x releases, and not 1.x.y releases. As they put more functionality in datapacks to replace mods (for example, we’re done with LambDynamicLights over a datapack) the fact that there are 4 major pack versions in the 1.20.x cycle and 3 in the 1.21.x cycle is nuts. I think all pack format changes (that are not bug fix) should be held behind experimental. I also think the actual feature release that impacts tags and resource packs (like new mobs and items) really should be in 1.x releases.
I would prefer
- Major changes to be locked to major 1.x version updates and limited to 2x/year
- Datapack and resource pack changes to be locked to the 1.x cycle
- Things in drops should be locked to experimental even if feature complete until the next 1.x
- 1.x.y should be non DP/RP changing updates (mechanic refinement for example like the minecart change or changing loot tables) and anything outside of that should be experimental toggle
- Minecraft should at a minimum refine the datapack format to enable storing variables in a format other than the scoreboard, and to support custom block and entity models, as it allows the replacement of a lot of mod functions with datapacks, and datapacks have a lower bar to entry to maintain and develop (they require no compilation).
I don’t think the majority of players play the game that way. I think the development cycle is exemplary for a project of this scope. We need more games with such an structured and open approach.
The Minecraft revolution already happened, Java is your gateway to anything imaginable. Just mod.
To bedrock players maybe , but as a java player too I think it’s reductive to just use mods to fix everything
I think it just offers open collaboration and voluntary usage of said fixes. But I mainly use mods to expand the game.
It is always fun to mod Minecraft heck it has its own huge community though your average player doesn’t tinker as much, but hey that something that Minecraft could improve upon the modding API.
Most people should just use CurseFordge even if it bothers you for that stupid Overwolf app. Its just convenient if you dont want to tinker but still play mods. I’m honestly just blown away how all these years later I can still relate to Minecraft with my own damn kids. Though they dont particularly like Skyblocks like I do.
Oh That’s awesome ,see imagine if your kids could easily tinker with the game even without programming knowledge or a simplified API for it wouldn’t that be great? And that’s just a small example for the potential this game has all game modes,mods, improvements, that could make Minecraft even more playable to an even bigger audience across generations these are the ideas I’d like to hear in this thread because it’s fun
Theres literally a click and install GUI now. They have command blocks now. IMO opinion those are the friendly steps to getting into it. They dont need another layer of obfuscation. They need a fun journey that gets them used to the reality. Minecraft does not need help getting bigger. People need less black boxes and more thoughtful exposure.
one request: for the love of God PLEASE just add the old terrain generation back but with the new biomes.
I want to feel like I can change the world with my own hands. I like flat land and to make one now I need to make a TNT duper (now requires a mod) to destroy a mountain that’s WAYYY too big anyways. They made the reliance on elytra worse instead of better.
I just want minecart hallways, but those don’t work large scale anymore :(
They need to add “teleportation” portals in vanilla. I don’t like nether hubs and I have to enable cheats to use command blocks. I want achievements AND the ability to craft two blocks/portals that serve as a way to jump to each other without the need to add command etc. just place one at your base, explore, and place one where you set up something else like a mine or other build. Then activate. It would make it more fun IMO. And possibilities are endless for its applications.
There is technically a “vanilla” way to do it with end gateways unfortunately it’s very limited since it works in the end only , if it were to work in the over world it would be so good, I like this idea to have it in survival sounds like a Worthy end game treasure.
Yea I ended up having to give up achievements in my worlds so I could use command blocks for this. I made a base 10K block or so and I wanted to connect them. Nether hubs have flaws where you can end up in the wrong portal sometimes. So much easier with a pressure plate and command block. Then switch back to survival but I couldn’t get anymore achievements. Making a dedicated teleport block that either links to another or you can just input coordinates without it being a cheat is essential. Like some OG games Zelda, Mario, Crash etc have ways you can jump within the game universe when you have completed an area, no cheats needed. It should seem that there would be a special item that is added in an update that can make a portal or type of “table” to give this function. Also they need to fix maps on console. I want to mark my location and others like java with banners, no mods.
agreed it’s unfortunate that suggestions like these don’t get much traction on the feedback website,i haven’t tinkered in minecraft nbt data for years i might get back to it. to see if there is a vanilla way to do it on the overworld
Feedback has now mostly moved to the discord, https://discord.gg/minecraftfeedback
TBH I think the game has been heading in the right course. The devs are pretty in tune with the community and most complaints I’ve had with the new features have faded as I’ve encountered them properly.
That said, c o m b a t r o l l
Spheres.
Or hear me out hyper cubes!
It is being revolutionized. Just look up Luanti.
oh? who are they?
Someone decided to make “Minecraft, but right”, and created an engine with the bare minimum, which you can then flesh out with whatever extension you like.
That sounds awesome
