“At 9:43 EDT, the devs decided collectively to do a “rollback” to the previous release. This was the worst possible mistake,”
No, the WORST POSSIBLE MISTAKE was doing a major roll out, then NO ONE STICKING AROUND TO WATCH WHAT HAPPENED! Seriously, who does this?? It’s like lighting the fuse on your firework show, then having an all hands staff meeting in a sound proofed trailer with blackout curtains.
Why does hft even exist? Does it have any value?
Short answer:
It gave us compiler explorer, now that it has served its purpose we should stop doing it.Long answer:
Why does hft even exist?
Hft can exist because most stock markets react to requests as fast as possible and have no noticable fees for certain use cases. This means algorithms that do simple trades like if goggle goes up, buy other tech companies or buy any stock that goes up in europe on the NY market can make small profits if they are faster than everyone else.
Does it have any value?
There is one exchange that imposes a delay on every request, effectively inhibiting hft, and its opening actually improved market conditions on all exchanges. This implies it has negative value.
They also spend millions on hardware, tools and developers to skim small sums of many transaction on the stock market. They are effectively a (very inefficient) tax on the stock market that goes to improving C++ compilers and funding hardware startups.
The actual SEC report is relatively short - and surprisingly accessible.
Quora just sucks big time
Weird that they used quora of all places this news was reported.
May I ask why? Edit: A genuine question. Sometimes Quora answers popup in my search, but I didn’t see any particular problem with it. Other than the AI answers.
Not OP but I’ve noticed a lot of racists, extreme right nationalists, religious chauvinists, etc. Which sucks because the concept is quite cool and I’d love to be able to jump from one question to the next, but pretty quickly I get irritated and have to close it.
Mhmm, okay then. So that means not enough or good enough moderation. I will keep an eye if I see such search results again.
I spent countless hours writing quality content there. Fuck quora. I’ll never make any content for companies again.
Now what was the cause of the bug? Fat fingering human error during release.
There isn’t a singular “the” cause usually, and if we do want to press for it, I’d say an aggressive deadline for a major product that needs engineers to slave away was the cause. At that point bugs become stastically inevitable. Whoever decided on that promised deadline was the first responsible person.
And nothing of value was lost
