Happy to see a privacy-focused carrier, and it has better policies than any other carrier out there. But founder is formerly from Palantir and there’s a lot of VC money behind it (not inherently a problem, just flagging).
Thoughts?
I just assume every ad on reddit is a scam. Seems to be the trend over there.
Hell half of the front page posts seem to be ads anymore
100% honeypot
Big encrochat vibes
Something can’t be both “100%” and vibes based lol
Unless you mean “I am 100% basing the following opinion on vibes”.
You need evidence. Please don’t respond with more vibes.
I am sure it is a honeypot, they will work with feds. I base that on the people behind it.
Also it reminds me a lot of encrochat which had similar vibes about it.
This is depressing. Trial by vibes. I’m going to live in the woods.
Im not basing anything on vibes, this is how venture capital funded operations work.
If you expect some rich assholes to keep your chats secure and not cave after the slightest preasure, you’re going to get taken for a ride.
Which is why it’s a honey pot it’s basically for gullible people.
I can’t believe I need to explain to someone that claiming you don’t need evidence to declare something to be true is faith based on vibes. Tiktok has truly broken the younger generations brains.
I cant believe i beed to explain to someone that venture capitalists are not good at security and do will not fight legal battles for the sake of their users. I linked multiple examples, believe what you want.
[citation needed]
It’s two separate sentences, my guy… complete with a line break in between. So not even in the same paragraph. Did we just forget how to parse written language?
Uh, he confirmed in a reply that he had no evidence and was deciding based on faith alone.
It looks like a honeypot, and wtf is a “private cell network”? How are they gonna do that? SMS and phone calls aren’t E2EE
It’s private because it’s yours /s
I’ve seen this ad here in Australia where cell towers are essentially all owned by a single telecomm (Telstra), who leases them out. No idea how their cell network could be private given that info
Gonna guess a company that has no problem engaging with Reddit’s invasive targeted ad system is not that privacy conscious.
Jmp.chat provides sim activations for xmr but honestly no matter what anything with a cell radio is being logged by its upstream carrier.
If you want a truely private number, use jmp.chat with a separate xmpp server over something like mullvad.
For what its worth, the sim swap protection might be worth it considering how many services force you to use SMS for 2fa, and they seem to ask for less data than usual.
Is it better than your average carrier? Maybe. Is any SMS/phone call coming out of your personal number something you should consider private from the government? Probably not.
Its still going to have to go over the big boy carriers, and its still probably going to be tied to a phone number several institutions will know is yours if its your main number.
If it isn’t, use jmp.chat, alongside a good XMPP provider and VPN, or forego the PSTN all-together.
“Is any SMS/phone call coming out of your personal number something you should consider private from the government? Probably not.”
Well your phone calls themselves – the actual conversation – shouldn’t be accessible without a warrant for a wire tap, that’s pretty longstanding precedent in the U.S. Cell phone location information is also protected by a warrant (Carpenter v. U.S.), but pen registers (logs of who you call) do not require a warrant (Smith v. Maryland). I’m not sure if governments are prevented from purchasing data from carriers, just as any data broker could do. Additionally, who knows if governments are secretly collecting phone call and cell phone data and storing it, but only accessing it once they have a warrant. It’s impossible to know what’s fully happening on the back end between big telco companies and the gov’t.
Either way, at the end of the day, whether you have Cape or some other service, if you’re at the level of the government getting a warrant for your data any legitimate company is going to comply. That’s why the best thing is to have a company that can only turn over limited amounts of data because that’s all they have.
Palantir, end of discussion.
It’s also like $100 a month.
True, expensive. Prosper to offset no selling customer data.
I refuse to believe they didn’t do this for their benefit. Especially at the price tag. I feel the same about Proton. The minute the government knocks without a warrant they’ll still turn you over.
Maybe, I couldn’t say if it’s a premium for privacy, marketing, or what.
As for turning over data without a warrant, I don’t have a problem with companies complying with lawful orders, as Proton does. I don’t think there’s any evidence to support the notion that Proton complies with non-legal or mere requests from LE. Correct me if I’m wrong.
I think their tech works, they’re used by the army. The founder was the cofounder of Palantir, which I think is worth noting. Their focus is on US government use first and the average consumer second.
Yeah it looks like the cell network is the consumer facing product
This is the exact reason that it is a hard no.
How would this be private? Wouldn’t they be using other providers cell network? I doubt they have put out enough or their own towers.
Also how do I pay for it they never now my name or address to I have to put cash in an envelope and drop it somewhere? Ah they don’t store the data on your payment but Stripe does.
So lots of this can be bullshit since they can claim we don’t collect data but they would be an MVNO but whichever network you are using does.
I saw this video on YouTube with a rep from the company and while there were some positive things put forward, the biggest red flag to me was when he wouldn’t disclose what networks they partner with. They are a virtual network so they don’t own the cell towers, and that means they’re running off someone else’s. Why can’t you say who? Other virtual carriers have no problem saying that they run on Verizon or T-Mobile.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K1C-bR728ro interview for Cape starts at about 30 minutes in. Ironically, the podcast is called “Snake Oilers” and it’s a paid-promotion thing, sooooo take this with a grain of salt.
Could be a honeypot.
That’s always the concern with privacy-focused services, especially if they’re not open source or audited.
But if we think about the practical application – who needs a honeypot for cell phone services? Carriers already collect so much data (location, telemetry, payment, government-issued ID, etc) and sell it willingly to whoever wants to buy. How could Cape be any worse? lol. If they adhere to any of their stated policies it seems like a plus, no?
Additionally, at least to me, Cape is not marketing the way the Anom phone did, where it trying to gain adopting by nefarious users. That’s my take - I’m not advocating for Cape since I don’t really know much about them, but I’m trying to put things in context.
The way anti-fingerprinting techniques work is by making you as much of a background digital character as possible. A privacy conscious user spoofing location and network traffic data on AT&T, Verizon, or T-Mobile is going to be far less likely to be singled out compared to customers on some bespoke cell network.
You should try to fake your traffic on a standard phone network (Using something like GrapheneOS with more granular control) to simply appear like another faceless data point rather than a “paranoid privacy user who bought this subscription for the privacy people”, because that traffic will raise eyebrows much quicker.
Fair points. Different strategies for different threat models I assume. Anonymity through hardening (if we take Cape at their word, big if) or security through obscurity.
Just use Airalo.
I don’t think this is really a replacement for the offering that Cape is proposing. Airalo are data only eSIMs and target consumers who need short-term data plans while traveling abroad. This is not a replacement of your primary carrier service and doesn’t give you a phone number. Additionally, other than the transient nature of the temporary eSIM you buy, there are no notable privacy-focused features behind Airalo.
Not saying Cape follows through with its claims, just saying these are not really comparable offerings.
I think they mean private as in, not a publicly traded company. Palantir would never ever ever respect anyone’s privacy, and under no circumstances ever can it be assumed that they will have ethical business practices.
This is a hard no. Fuck Palantir. Also, fuck Theil too. Hope he rots.
What? Lol.









