• 3 Posts
  • 189 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 15th, 2023

help-circle

  • but I’m not sure how to find one of these with name brand relays that id actually trust in a commercial setting.

    I suppose that comes down to “what is the worst case scenario assuming the board fails”. If you simply can’t have it fail the design should have redundancies built in. If you’re looking for build quality/established MTBF ratings then piggyback on top of someone elses regulatory approvals where those tolerances are built in. I just did a quick google search for “relay board FAA approved” not even knowing what the regulatory rules are of aircraft. Apparently those are FAA-PMA and TSO. Plugging that in with “relay board” and you get something like this:

    Sandia Aerospace 12 Pole Switching Relay

    This level of build quality and certification comes at a much higher price of $524 for one board though. Another choice I might chase would be “medical”.





  • My hypotheticals got you to think about more than just money,

    Sigh, I’m sorry to disappoint you, but I had already thought though all of those before.

    which is my point: there’s more to a job than money.

    I’m perfectly aware of that. You’re getting close to my ultimate point, which ultimately is: There’s more to life than a job

    If I could get a wage to live a minimally comfortable life with the occasional semestral luxury and the job were a dream, you couldn’t pay me enough to work at any shitty employer.

    Sure, but those jobs/employers are increasingly rare, and when the need exist to find a replacement like that it is even more rare. Unless you’re within perhaps 5 years of retirement right now, the likelihood you’re going to find your described desired job that will last for the rest of your working life looks very unlikely to me. If that’s your plan, I wish you luck.

    With that out of the way, since your hypothetical is purely about money and nothing else, no job satisfaction, no evil deeds of the employer, no questionable ethics, no seeing the kids for 1-2 years, no functional relationship for the same amount of time, no work life balance, no travel distance, no in office mandate, no sense of belonging with my current employer, nothing but money and I somehow fell on my head to ignore all of that…sure, I’d be a selfish capitalist pig and switch jobs.

    That isn’t what I asked. You’re changing the hypothetical I posted, then answered your changed one. With our handful of interactions, I believe I have a good understanding of your thought process and how you approach an issue now. I have heard what you believe and you have heard a part of my argument. Thank you for conversing up to now.


  • Great hypothetical that doesn’t translate to the real world, so I’m not sure why I should consider it.

    Its not supposed to be a real world example. Its an exaggerated hypothetical to prove a point. You should consider it because its an exercise in isolating one specific element to measure your own response to just that element without distraction of other (possibly relevant) points.

    I can make hypotheticals too. What if the dickish employer leads to burn out 80% of the time that most people take years to recover from. Would you take the chance?

    If you’re extending my hypothetical, hell yes I would! I would work 2 years earn enough money to never have to work again. The future “years of recovery” would be doing whatever I wanted.

    I think you may be making the assumption that if you didn’t take the dickish employer position, that you’d be guaranteed 20 years of non-dickish employer employment. If you’ve been watching the job market over the last 10 years, I think you should know that isn’t likely.

    The result of staying with non-dickish employer is that you may be 6-8 years tops at non-dickish employer getting simple cost-of-living raises, but never advancing beyond your position, and possibly not allowing you to save enough for retirement at the lifestyle you want to live. Then some year in the future your non-dickish employer gets bought out by private equity or put out of business by a competitor multinational company. So then you’re back in the job market with a very high likelihood of only having dickish employers to choose from for future employment for the next 8-12 years.

    Meanwhile, your former co-worker worked for dickish employer for 2 years, cashed out, and travels the world with his wife studying history while his wife paints because thats what they like to do with their time.

    What if 2 year is guaranteed to give you a lifelong trauma. Would you take the chance?

    Depends on the definition of trauma in your specific hypothetical. I’d argue all employers cause some level and type of trauma. So it would be a discussion of degrees and how it manifests.

    Or hey, what if working at that employer means you have to do things like write code that kills humans and they are then used in your country? What if earning 10x means your kids will never know privacy again and you contributed to it. Worth the 10x?

    That doesn’t meet my definition of dickish employer. What you’re describing here is far worse. You’re proving my point with my original hypothetical that was isolating just pay.

    I’ve answered your hypothetical would you like to answer mine now?



  • Same as always: treat them well, pay them fairly, don’t be a dick. It’s quite easy actually.

    How about a hypothetical:

    Take your current paycheck amount, now multiply it by 10. That’s the pay offer from the other probably dickish company. If you last even just 1 year at dickish employer, you can take the next nine years off and still be ahead financially. If you last 2 years, you may be financially set and done working for the rest of your life.

    Would you stay at your current employer?


  • Full disclosure, I’m not a senior developer, but a senior elsewhere in IT facing this exact same situation.

    Like the author, I’ve also identified our cannibalism of our juniors with the obvious future consequences to this if continued unabated. I’ve struggled with how to combat this, and I really give the author lots of credit for producing actual actionable plans on a path forward.

    The main failure mode I see for the proposal is organizational self interest. Investing in juniors made sense in the past because the junior work (grunt work) was needed completion anyway so the exercise of training produced a useful result while also freeing up cycles for seniors to engage in higher level work. The result is that the training of the junior became partially subsidized by their output. Today that isn’t really the case. A senior with an agentic workflow can likely produce the same result as the junior with only a rounding error of effort. This shifts the organizational incentive model significantly to the point were training the junior is purely a cost sink with only a negligible return to the organization.

    The author points out properly that systemically across the industry cannibalizing juniors eventually means cannibalizing future seniors, but wrongly assumes that training juniors inside the organization means producing seniors long term in the organization. Unless the entire industry adopts the new system to train juniors there will be organizations that simply poach juniors that have been trained up. Money is fungible. If it takes money to train the junior an org could take those same dollars and offer relatively obscene salaries to trained juniors.

    From my view, seems like it will always be more expensive to train than to hire those trained. What am I missing here? How can an org that trains up its juniors (using the author’s good suggestions on how) guarantee they keep their trained juniors (or at least retain enough to make the whole exercise worth it)?





  • It depends on what you mean by robotic mowers. If you mean motors that drive the wheels and you don’t have to walk behind them (or sit on them), yes, these exist without any cloud service. However, if you mean autonomous, then I don’t think those are here yet. The non-cloud robot mowers use human held remote controls.

    I can think of one that is autonomous and doesn’t require the cloud for operation, but does require the cloud for the inital setup and mapping. Once it has the map loaded in, it doesn’t need an internet connection.



  • For me, this cannot work, the results can only be considered good if the intentions were good. If you do something good out of bad intentions, then the result might be objectively good, but I won’t count it as something good from you.

    We’re bordering on reinventing Kantianism vs Utilitarianism arguments here because there is no objective definition of “good”. Each of us subjectively decides what is “good”. To illustrate with your position that the intent to do good is the deciding factor, then that would follow that Hitler would be good because his intent was to do “good” as he saw it. Obviously neither one of use would consider Hitler or his actions good.

    Here’s your statement with the extra dimension of intent we’re discussing added:

    If you do something good (and good by my standard) out of bad intentions (good by your own standards), then the result might be objectively bad, but I won’t count it as something good from you (because even though your intent was good by your standards your result was bad from my standards).

    Doesn’t this seems to negate the “intent” element argument returning judgment purely base end result judgment?





  • Yellow jackets on the other hand are complete assholes. We had a nest of them in the yard once and they would go way out of their way to sting people, just for the hell of it.

    This was my experience too. I had thought that bees had moved into a bush in my yard. I was happy to have bees there. A week later I was mowing the grass and felt several stabs of pain on my back and wrist. I turn around and see the air is filled with them. I had swatted one in my escape and had a corpse to inspect later and found it was a Yellow jacket wasp. From a distance I could see they were entering and exiting a hole near the bottom of the bush. A quick internet search later I knew that they were nearly dormant at night, and that they need a special oil they produce on the outside of their body to breath. Dawn dish soap apparently strips that away and they die, and its not toxic to the ground or environment.

    I put half a bottle of Dawn squirted into their hole at the bottom of the bush at night. I never saw another Yellowjack wasp.